One would expect Sai devotees to turn to their know-all guru and God for illumination as to the causes of the undersea earthquake and consequent tsunami calamities. What would they find?

Sai Baba in the media - Year 2005 ( 15, 2005)
Shun hatred: Sai Baba Deccan Chronicle, India
Satya Sai Baba of Puttaparthi said on Saturday that natural calamities like tsunami should not be treated as punishment from the God. ...

Sathya Sai Baba on calamaties and their cause

Sai baba on natural disasters' causes

So it is all the fault of 'man', not least 'scientists' seeking 'unrestricted enjoyment'. However, since such major earthquake calamities took place for millions of years before and during humanity's emergence and are known to be caused by the regular releases through aeons of vast pressures built up in the gradually-moving continental tectonic plates, Sai Baba's connection to "man's conduct" it is really a tough conundrum to solve! This kind of talk may satisfy (and misinform) poor peasants or cringing servitors, but no one with a smattering of education can rationalise this away. Click here to see 'Stark Effects of a Seismic Shift' by Ian Sample, 'The Guardian's science correspondent.

But wait, could it have been a wrong translation or misquote by Sai Baba's translator/editor at the time, V.K. Narasimhan? Definitely not, for I often saw Narasimhan working on translations of Baba's Telugu and Sanskrit and he explained his process in detail. He was very thorough and generally very accurate. However, he also told me of numerous things he he omitted and modified to suppress the worst of Sai Baba's mistakes, confusions of facts and theoretical absurdities when translating. He was worried about his reputation if he were found out. This can now be told since poor old Narasimhan died in 2000.

Just to show that Sai Baba really meant what he said, consider his following statement about one year later:-

Sai Baba on catastrophes adn their human cause
(also at page 342 Sathya Sai Speaks Vol. 27)

The kind of conduct, to which Sai Baba attributes all the ills of the world, is "spiritual lapses". How spiritual lapses cause Nature to cause calamities is what Sai Baba cannot explain. That the earth loses its physical balance (too much weight on one side!) is presumably also a result of 'spiritual lapses'? ("Only He knows!"). He is as ignorant of plate techtonics and the shifting continents as he is of incredibly accurate modern measurement techniques of gravity aided by sattelite. He can tell of no observable or other precise connecting links which anyone can believe in (except perhaps Indra worshippers and the like). It is all postulation and arises from the primitive pre-scientific misunderstanding of causes of man's afflictions, whether it be illnesses like leprosy, or otherwise avoidable accidents, or anything the empirical causes of which were unknown to our relatively very ignorant and superstitious forefathers and the many and various faulty 'religious tenets' they have handed down to us.

Still uncertain whether Sai Baba can be so ignorant, vague and pompously absurd? Try the following for size then:-

"What is the cause of droughts and floods which occur in the world? Man seeks to enjoy the benefits of Nature which has grave consequences. Here you have a globe. If you hit it one way, its balance is disturbed. We should always see to it that the utilisation of natural resources a proper balance is kept. Excessive use in one direction will result in harm in another direction."
p. 282, Sanathana Sarathi November, 1997 -- or - p. 241-242, Sathya Sai Speaks Vol. 30.

Such a gifted account of how droughts and floods occur! This super-simplistic distortion of the idea of ecological balance would not even be accepted by elementary school students nowadays. One could forgive Sathya Sai Baba his profound ignorance of undisputable facts and lack of standard education were it not for the arrogant and all-knowing manner with which he uses these falsehoods to try to impress his listeners and even to cow people into submission to his 'spiritual teaching'. He has also pointed out that "the Lord" sets examinations! See how he justifies calamities....

Sai Baba on testing a man

Sathya Sai Baba was the victim of a vague report of an earthquake that was to hit Puttaparthi, causing people to flee. See Earthquake Alarm in Puttaparthi

1) Print this Page
      2) Use right click here - then 'Open page in new window' to translate 

Click here to return to top overview page